Get a Free Quote
Give us your name and number and we'll call you back right away.

Please fill this field.

Insurance Products We Offer

With a variety of insurance companies to choose from, we can shop the market for the coverage you need, at a price you can afford.

Auto Insurance
Classic & Antique Car Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Jewelry, Furs, & Collectibles Insurance

Business Insurance
Commercial Property Insurance
Contractors Insurance
Workers Compensation Insurance
Commercial Auto Insurance

The Shay Agency

We are committed to excellence. Since our founding, we have been working hard to ensure our clients receive the best possible insurance services. Our team of professionals offer unparalleled customer support and expert advice.

We are independently owned, locally operated, and we work for you to find the best insurance products available for your particular needs. We want to ensure that you get to keep what you have worked hard to acquire. Asset protection is the surest way to preserve your wealth. We are committed to maintaining the highest standards of integrity and professionalism in our relationship with you, our client.

Not all insurance agents are the same! Choosing the right one can make a BIG difference – in price, service, and value.

Learn more about what we do by contacting one of our professional consultants for a free estimate. You’ll be delighted to learn what we can offer for you, your family, and your business.

Read testimonials from some of our satisfied customers.

See More Testimonials

Best agency I have dealt with. At 68 years of age and also being in the automotive industry I have literally communicated with many hundreds of insurance agencies. This one has my policies, that should say it all. Cindy and Melissa are the best

- Richard W.

Sean has been my agent since 2010, and I truly can't emphasize enough how amazing he has been from the very beginning. No other agency has ever provided a lower quote than he has, and this holds true for everyone I've sent his way as well. His dedication, reliability, and extensive knowledge are truly remarkable. Over the past 15 years, Sean has consistently shown that he is fully committed to his clients.

- Christi C.

Michelle Schott handled my Flood Insurance and was the ultimate professional. She is very personable as well as truly diligent.

- John G.

I have trusted the Shay Agency and the entire team(Sean, Cindy, Michelle and Melissa) with my personal insurance for 10+ years. Then as I started my own business their expertise, guidance and customer service really knocked it out of the park. Highly recommend for anyone whether personal or business insurance.

- Peter H.